Full disclosure: the thing that I find most exciting about the advent of Deathly Hallows is the sense of completion. I want to know what really happens to Harry and everyone else in the wizarding world. I think that the fic will only be better (at least for the next few years) as new canon is absorbed and stretched and examined over and over again, in the way the community has already learned to do.
Speculation about what happens "off-screen" and "after" will be even more satisfying to me, because nothing else can change canon. Take Firefly fic: about three-quarters is Firefly + Big Damn Movie compliant, and the other quarter is happily and unapologetically compliant only to series canon. Any future additions to the world of Harry Potter will be similar, in that it will not alter the fundamental arc JKR has given us in the seven part series. We would certainly learn more about the wizarding world, and we would probably be given new canon that we could use or disregard, but nothing could change the fundamental completeness of the seven-part canon that's about to be...uh, complete.
I do feel for those who can't achieve the cognitive dissonance necessary to write non-DH-compliant fic after they have read DH and therefore have to abandon their projects. I know that there are writers who already do beautiful work that isn't HBP- or even OOTP-compliant. Hopefully all of the threads of character those who are in mid-project rely on will stay intact, and/or hopefully they'll be able to forge ahead and make canon their own, just like all of the non-HBP-compliant writers have been doing since the last book came out. After all, so much of what I believe about the many faces and personalities of Harry Potter comes from the fanfic community. And look how well Snupin writers have done explaining away Tonks...!
I have the feeling that this opinions puts me in the minority in fandom, but I can't be the only one. I love fic and the people who breathe life into it for me, and to know that all of you writers out there will have a bigger toolbox makes me look forward to August even more (well, that, and I get to go on vacation for two weeks).
I'm not sure I'm really making a point here, but in the past few weeks, I've started to think that maybe I'll be able to join the written chorus a little, once I know how it all ends. (I'm also writing a thesis, working part-time, going to school, launching a web site, moving apartments [TWO WEEKS, OH NOES!], and looking for a "real" job, not to mention becoming a better beta-reader and reccer...so it might take a while for me to actually produce something worth reading.)
Anyway, thanks for letting me come along for the ride. I'm tingly-toed about the countdown, and extremely bummed that there will be four or five ETERNALLY LONG DAYS between when DH comes out and when I can get my fingers on a copy. And then I'm going to angst about how quickly I read, and try to slow down and savor it, only I won't because I had the same feeling for HBP and still plowed through it in under four hours the first time I read it.
More recs coming: I have dozens of stories and artsies bookmarked. Okay, okay, maybe I could use another month or three between now and 7/21...
Speculation about what happens "off-screen" and "after" will be even more satisfying to me, because nothing else can change canon. Take Firefly fic: about three-quarters is Firefly + Big Damn Movie compliant, and the other quarter is happily and unapologetically compliant only to series canon. Any future additions to the world of Harry Potter will be similar, in that it will not alter the fundamental arc JKR has given us in the seven part series. We would certainly learn more about the wizarding world, and we would probably be given new canon that we could use or disregard, but nothing could change the fundamental completeness of the seven-part canon that's about to be...uh, complete.
I do feel for those who can't achieve the cognitive dissonance necessary to write non-DH-compliant fic after they have read DH and therefore have to abandon their projects. I know that there are writers who already do beautiful work that isn't HBP- or even OOTP-compliant. Hopefully all of the threads of character those who are in mid-project rely on will stay intact, and/or hopefully they'll be able to forge ahead and make canon their own, just like all of the non-HBP-compliant writers have been doing since the last book came out. After all, so much of what I believe about the many faces and personalities of Harry Potter comes from the fanfic community. And look how well Snupin writers have done explaining away Tonks...!
I have the feeling that this opinions puts me in the minority in fandom, but I can't be the only one. I love fic and the people who breathe life into it for me, and to know that all of you writers out there will have a bigger toolbox makes me look forward to August even more (well, that, and I get to go on vacation for two weeks).
I'm not sure I'm really making a point here, but in the past few weeks, I've started to think that maybe I'll be able to join the written chorus a little, once I know how it all ends. (I'm also writing a thesis, working part-time, going to school, launching a web site, moving apartments [TWO WEEKS, OH NOES!], and looking for a "real" job, not to mention becoming a better beta-reader and reccer...so it might take a while for me to actually produce something worth reading.)
Anyway, thanks for letting me come along for the ride. I'm tingly-toed about the countdown, and extremely bummed that there will be four or five ETERNALLY LONG DAYS between when DH comes out and when I can get my fingers on a copy. And then I'm going to angst about how quickly I read, and try to slow down and savor it, only I won't because I had the same feeling for HBP and still plowed through it in under four hours the first time I read it.
More recs coming: I have dozens of stories and artsies bookmarked. Okay, okay, maybe I could use another month or three between now and 7/21...
2 comments | Leave a comment
